Are you a peanut butter aficionado? Do you love your peanut butter cups, cookies, and sandwiches? If you love peanut butter on almost anything and must stop yourself from eating it straight from the jar, you might be a genuine peanut butter lover.

Even if your love for peanut butter hasn’t reached such extreme levels, you probably still have a favorite brand of peanut butter. Maybe you’ve eaten the same brand since you were a kid, or you’ve tried several brands over the years.

Peanut butter is a delicious, healthy source of protein, vitamins, and minerals. It’s one of the healthiest things you can eat, but unfortunately, commercial peanut butter often contains extra ingredients such as emulsifiers and stabilizers. These extras turn whole peanuts into empty calories.

What kinds of peanut butter are best?

Natural peanut butter usually doesn’t contain a lot of extra ingredients. Some natural peanut butter formulas contain only peanuts and salt. This means most natural peanut butter requires stirring after they’re opened. The oils in peanut butter naturally rise to the surface when emulsifiers aren’t added.

If you’ve never tried natural peanut butter before, stay with us, we’re about to introduce you to the best natural peanut butter brands around.

Why Choose Natural Peanut Butter?

best natural peanut butter

Image by Steve Buissinne from Pixabay

Isn’t all peanut butter healthy? Why should you switch to natural peanut butter when your current brand still tastes so good?

Well, commercial peanut butter can contain potentially harmful fats and added sugars. These calories add no benefit to your peanut butter. The main reason these additives are in the peanut butter is to improve the texture and eliminate the need for stirring.

Added sugar could be harmful to you if you’re prediabetic or suffer from diabetes because some brands contain lots of added sugar.

Some have hydrogenated oils, otherwise known as trans fats, which cause fat retention instead of fat burning in your body.

Natural peanut butter, on the other hand, usually has only two ingredients: peanuts and salt. By skipping the additives, you’re getting more fiber and less filler.

Both kinds of  peanut butter have lots of mono- and poly-unsaturated fats, which are said to be heart healthy, but regular peanut butter also has trans fats, which are linked to heart disease.

So, it’s time for you to check out your options for the best natural peanut butter on the market. You might have to get used to the grainier texture, and the need for stirring, but after a while, you might like the flavor of natural peanut butter better.

How We Chose Our Ratings

best natural peanut butter

Image by cgdsro from Pixabay  

You might wonder how we choose our ratings. Well, it’s simple. We know honest and accurate information is crucial to helping you make an informed decision.

We look at professional blog reviews as well as customer product reviews to find a variety of opinions. Then, we evaluate our list according to several standards, including brand reputation and customer service. We know some brands have been in business for a long time and have developed brand loyalty from their customers.

It’s also important to pay attention to the ingredients, the nutrition facts, the consistency, and the taste of all the peanut butter we’re considering to determine if they should be on the list, and where they should go. Great natural peanut butter doesn’t have a lot of additive ingredients or lots of salt.

The flavor of the peanuts and the consistency of the product are foremost in our minds. When you shop for natural peanut butter, you are looking for food where the main ingredient is the star of the show.  We looked for peanut butter that featured the flavor of the peanut.

Finally, we rank each product on our list out of 5 stars. Every item is excellent, but they’re ranked from best to worst in descending order. We hope you’re able to find something on our list to satisfy your peanut butter cravings.

Top 5 Best Natural Peanut Butter Brands

Now, here is our list of the best natural peanut butter brands out there. We hope you’ll give one or more of them a try. Maybe you’ll find a brand-new favorite.

The top-rated peanut butter on our list is one you can probably find in your local supermarket. Smucker’s Natural Peanut Butter is a common brand, but it’s well worth the hype. Unlike many natural peanut butters, you won’t have to refrigerate this peanut butter.

Which is economical for a natural peanut butter. Smucker’s sticks to the simple recipe of peanuts and salt, and no other ingredients.

Customers who praise this peanut butter are often long-time customers who love the simple taste and unique texture of this product. Some are gluten sensitive and like the low carbohydrate content of this peanut butter. Other long-time customers complain that the formula for this product has changed recently, and while they still enjoy it, they don’t like it as much.

Overall, customers were complimentary of the taste, texture, and price of this peanut butter.

Justin's Classic Peanut Butter, 16 oz (Pack of 2)
  • (2) 16 oz Jars of Justin's Classic Peanut Butter

Continuing their line of delicious nut butters, Justin’s Peanut Butter comes in either a pouch or a jar. This peanut butter has only peanuts and palm oil, but no added salt. This peanut butter is not as budget-friendly as other products on this list.

The palm oil gives this product a thicker consistency than some of the other natural peanut butters, but it also adds some additional saturated fat. Reviewers found this an extremely thick peanut butter, probably best eaten with fruit or thinned out in yogurt.

While many customers enjoyed it, others thought it suffered for its lack of salt. Some thought it was too thick, as well.

Overall, most customers were satisfied with this product, despite the price and the consistency.

Whole Foods’ brand 365 Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter. It’s made with peanuts and salt and must be refrigerated after opening. This is another peanut butter you’ll need to stir after opening.

It has a runny consistency, which some reviewers didn’t like, but after a few hours in the fridge, it should harden a bit and be easier to spread. Also, some reviewers mentioned you could pour off a little bit of the oil and the consistency would be thicker.

Most knowledgeable reviewers were complimentary of the simple, no-frills taste of this peanut butter. They appreciated the focus on the flavors of the peanuts. Other consumers seemed unfamiliar with how natural peanut butters work.

They were put off by the oil at the top of the jar. If you’ve never encountered this before, perhaps a no-stir natural peanut butter is better for you.

Overall, most customers were satisfied with this peanut butter and would buy it again.

Maranatha Organic Peanut Butter, Creamy, 16 Ounce
  • USDA Organic
  • Certified Organic by QAI
  • Hint of Sea Salt
  • Gluten Free

MaraNatha makes several types of peanut butter, but the most popular seems to be the MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter. This product is made of peanuts and salt and comes in crunchy and creamy varieties.

Even though this peanut butter requires some stirring, reviewers noted it didn’t need as much stirring as other natural peanut butters. After a bit of stirring, the texture resembled regular peanut butter without needing to be refrigerated first.

The flavor is top-notch, though. It salty enough to enhance the flavors of the sweet peanuts without overpowering them with salt. The texture is much smoother than other natural peanut butters, and after a bit of stirring, it yields a good consistency that isn’t too thin or too thick.

Customers gave this product high marks for its consistency and flavor. Some noted that certain versions of MaraNatha products contain additives like palm oil, but they were glad to see this peanut butter does not.

Other customers complained that the brand seemed to be steering its marketing away from the peanut butter and toward the tree nut butters. They hoped this wouldn’t mean the brand would abandon the peanut butter.

Overall, most customers were satisfied and happy with this product.

Trader Joe's Creamy Unsalted Peanut Butter From Unblanched Peanuts
  • Trader Joe'S Creamy Unsalted Peanut Butter From Unblanched Peanuts
  • Refrigerate after opening

MaraNatha makes several types of peanut butter, but the most popular seems to be the MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter. This product is made of peanuts and salt and comes in crunchy and creamy varieties.

Even though this peanut butter requires some stirring, reviewers noted it didn’t need as much stirring as other natural peanut butters. After a bit of stirring, the texture resembled regular peanut butter without needing to be refrigerated first.

The flavor is top-notch, though. It salty enough to enhance the flavors of the sweet peanuts without overpowering them with salt. The texture is much smoother than other natural peanut butters, and after a bit of stirring, it yields a good consistency that isn’t too thin or too thick.

Customers gave this product high marks for its consistency and flavor. Some noted that certain versions of MaraNatha products contain additives like palm oil, but they were glad to see this peanut butter does not.

Other customers complained that the brand seemed to be steering its marketing away from the peanut butter and toward the tree nut butters. They hoped this wouldn’t mean the brand would abandon the peanut butter.

Overall, most customers were satisfied and happy with this product.

Comparison Table

Natural Peanut Butter Buyer’s Guide

best natural peanut butter

Image by Steve Buissinne from Pixabay

Now that you’ve seen our list of the best natural peanut butter brands, you might wonder at the variety found in food that has so few ingredients. Certainly, one natural peanut butter is much like another?

Well, yes and no. You’d be surprised at the different qualities you find between natural peanut butter brands. If you have issues with certain kinds of textures, you may need to try several brands before you find a grind that works for you.

You can also find peanut butter made with different kinds of peanuts or different amounts of salt. You can choose a brand based on your taste preference. You need to taste a lot of different natural peanut butters to know what you like.

Some of the things you might consider when trying a natural peanut butter are:

  • Crunchy Vs. Creamy: Natural creamy peanut butter isn’t going to have the same smoothness of regular creamy peanut butter because natural peanut butter has fewer emulsifiers and stabilizers. The good news is, if you love crunchy peanut butter, you’ll like natural crunchy peanut butter, which is grainier and has larger peanut pieces in it.
  • Stir Vs. No Stir: Most natural peanut butters naturally separate during settling and while being transported. This means you’ll have to stir your jar when you open it. If you don’t want to do this every time you open a brand-new jar of peanut butter, you can buy no-stir natural peanut butters.
  • Salt or No Salt: Salt is almost non-negotiable in most natural peanut butters, but there are some exceptions. A few brands don’t add any salt at all. If you have medical sodium restrictions or prefer unsalted foods, this might be a good option for you. 

Once you know what aspects of peanut butter are most important to you, you can choose the brand that’s right for you. When faced with the wide world of natural peanut butters, you’ll be able to narrow down the options easily. You only need to start with our suggestions and our buyer’s guide.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This